Difference between revisions of "Meeting 1 November 2019"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Created page with "DISCUSSION MATERIAL * [CPS FLUKA Comparison]") |
|||
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
DISCUSSION MATERIAL | DISCUSSION MATERIAL | ||
− | * [CPS FLUKA Comparison] | + | * [https://wiki.jlab.org/cuawiki/images/d/d0/Gn_cps_meeting_11_01_2019.pdf CPS FLUKA Comparison] |
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | ACTION ITEMS: | ||
+ | |||
+ | * (David H., Sean, Rolf, Donal, Tanja, ...) Finalize CPS article - target for submission: 22 November | ||
+ | ::* implement comments from Sean and Donal | ||
+ | ::* check figure captions | ||
+ | ::* add more detail on Hall D - Sean will send some text | ||
+ | ::* author list | ||
+ | |||
+ | * (Gabriel) Simulations in preparation for NSF MRI | ||
+ | ::* need radiation analysis on coil to determine what isolation material to use - for specific simulation specs see item 4a from 10/11 meeting (need one z-value) | ||
+ | ::* need some phi angles to see how much shielding to use - also item 4a | ||
+ | |||
+ | * (David H., Tanja) Funding proposal | ||
+ | ::* prepare an itemized budget for discussion | ||
+ | ::* prepare 1-2 page on CPS for David H funding proposal submission | ||
+ | |||
+ | * CPS collaboration meeting - determine date based on NPS agenda | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | DETAILS OF THE DISCUSSION | ||
+ | |||
+ | * CPS simulation update - step 0 is complete! | ||
+ | ::* Comparison of Parker Reid to Gabriel Niculescu simulations - they are consistent | ||
+ | ::* details of the simulations: | ||
+ | ::::* both based on cylindrical geometry | ||
+ | ::::* horizontal axis is the beam direction | ||
+ | ::::* vertical axis is transverse to beam direction AND integrated over all phi angles | ||
+ | ::* should still figure out what the events in the indicated box are - strange since no material there | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | * Discussion about next steps for simulation | ||
+ | ::* Insert intermediate steps before step 1 to determine material needed for CPS and cost estimate for funding proposal | ||
+ | ::::* complete step 4a for one z-value, factor 3 sufficient - choice of material | ||
+ | ::::* need phi angles bins - amount of shielding, radiation going into floor etc. | ||
+ | ::* step 1 involves comparison to an Hall C experiment, e.g. J/Psi, to verify activation after 1000 hours running etc. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | * Discussion about beam size in Hall D | ||
+ | ::* 10% radiator - take half the size (5%) and assume 11-12 GeV in Hall D - results in 2.5cm RMS after 80m | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | * Discussion about CPS article | ||
+ | ::* Comments from Donal coming | ||
+ | ::* David H. will implement comments from Sean, Donal, and check figure captions | ||
+ | ::* Additional authors - Sean will check with Justin on authorship | ||
+ | ::::* Add some text on Hall D | ||
+ | ::* Try to submit by 11/22 | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | * Discussion about funding proposal | ||
+ | ::* budget elementary: magnet and diagnostics | ||
+ | ::* require estimate for simulation step 4a, e.g., some phi values to see how much shielding to use and for radiation analysis of magnet coils and iteration with vendor | ||
+ | ::* assume JLab provides: support structure, cooling, safety for high radiation, beam line and beam line diagnostics | ||
+ | ::* David H. preparing UK funding proposal - include 1-2 pages on CPS; due date is end of November | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | * CPS collaboration meeting - plan for 3 February or 4 February 2020 | ||
+ | ::* need to check agenda for NPS collaboration meeting (3 Feb 2020) | ||
+ | ::* no obvious conflicts for either day | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | NEXT CPS PHONE MEETINGS: | ||
+ | * FRIDAY 15 NOVEMBER AT 11:00AM (ET) | ||
+ | * FRIDAY 22 NOVEMBER AT 11:00AM (ET) |
Latest revision as of 16:06, 1 November 2019
DISCUSSION MATERIAL
ACTION ITEMS:
- (David H., Sean, Rolf, Donal, Tanja, ...) Finalize CPS article - target for submission: 22 November
- implement comments from Sean and Donal
- check figure captions
- add more detail on Hall D - Sean will send some text
- author list
- (Gabriel) Simulations in preparation for NSF MRI
- need radiation analysis on coil to determine what isolation material to use - for specific simulation specs see item 4a from 10/11 meeting (need one z-value)
- need some phi angles to see how much shielding to use - also item 4a
- (David H., Tanja) Funding proposal
- prepare an itemized budget for discussion
- prepare 1-2 page on CPS for David H funding proposal submission
- CPS collaboration meeting - determine date based on NPS agenda
DETAILS OF THE DISCUSSION
- CPS simulation update - step 0 is complete!
- Comparison of Parker Reid to Gabriel Niculescu simulations - they are consistent
- details of the simulations:
- both based on cylindrical geometry
- horizontal axis is the beam direction
- vertical axis is transverse to beam direction AND integrated over all phi angles
- should still figure out what the events in the indicated box are - strange since no material there
- Discussion about next steps for simulation
- Insert intermediate steps before step 1 to determine material needed for CPS and cost estimate for funding proposal
- complete step 4a for one z-value, factor 3 sufficient - choice of material
- need phi angles bins - amount of shielding, radiation going into floor etc.
- step 1 involves comparison to an Hall C experiment, e.g. J/Psi, to verify activation after 1000 hours running etc.
- Discussion about beam size in Hall D
- 10% radiator - take half the size (5%) and assume 11-12 GeV in Hall D - results in 2.5cm RMS after 80m
- Discussion about CPS article
- Comments from Donal coming
- David H. will implement comments from Sean, Donal, and check figure captions
- Additional authors - Sean will check with Justin on authorship
- Add some text on Hall D
- Try to submit by 11/22
- Discussion about funding proposal
- budget elementary: magnet and diagnostics
- require estimate for simulation step 4a, e.g., some phi values to see how much shielding to use and for radiation analysis of magnet coils and iteration with vendor
- assume JLab provides: support structure, cooling, safety for high radiation, beam line and beam line diagnostics
- David H. preparing UK funding proposal - include 1-2 pages on CPS; due date is end of November
- CPS collaboration meeting - plan for 3 February or 4 February 2020
- need to check agenda for NPS collaboration meeting (3 Feb 2020)
- no obvious conflicts for either day
NEXT CPS PHONE MEETINGS:
- FRIDAY 15 NOVEMBER AT 11:00AM (ET)
- FRIDAY 22 NOVEMBER AT 11:00AM (ET)