Discussion 09-23-24

Speakers and participants, please review the guidance provided on the main page. This agenda page is editable by anyone that has a Jefferson Lab computing account. Feel free to log in and post comments, questions, or answers to questions in the section below.

Meeting Location

The 22 GeV Open Discussions will be held here:

• Date/Time: Monday, September 23 at 12:30 PM Jefferson Lab Local Time
• Physical Location: CEBAF Center F224/5
• Virtual Location: Zoom Meeting Number 161 111 8017 (The password is the two-digit number that appears before "GeV" in the first sentence of this section.)

Agenda

• Measuring the X(Y)Z at JLab22 (Sean Dobbs)

Comments and Questions

• (Add content here)

Minutes/Notes (D.S. Carman)

Local participants at JLab: 13; Remote participants: 33

• This presentation continued the discussion on studies of spectroscopy of the so-called X, Y, and Z mesons that was started by Alessandro Pilloni at the Sep. 9 22 GeV discussion with a focus on theory status. Today’s discussion centered instead on experimental considerations of such a program at JLab22.

• Presentation points:
  • Review of status:
    • Overview of the c-c (charmonium) spectrum augmented with the experimental evidence for the X, Y, and Z states.
    • Photoproduction experiments can have an impact on these studies to confirm states purported to have a non-q-q nature.
    • The most relevant modes for initial exploration at JLab22 would focus on X, Z decays to J/Ψ+π, J/Ψ+ππ (these would be the “discovery” modes).
    • Studies of γp → c-c are optimal using detectors with large acceptance - Hall B and Hall D at JLab.
  • Simulations are underway by Sean to study X and Z production in Hall D with GlueX:
    • Simulations have been done in the GlueX-II configuration based on the 2020 GlueX configuration without the DIRC, TRD, new high resolution FCAL.
    • Note that GlueX-III is approved to run at two times the luminosity of GlueX-II.
    • Studies have focused on γp → J/Ψ+π+π- running for 1 year, assuming a total cross section of 500 pb-1 with a BR of 5%.
      • Expected yields: N(Ψ(2S))=900, N(X(3872))=2300, N(Y(4260))=120
    • Another study has been done for γp → J/Ψ+πp to study both charged and neutral Zc states.
  • Simulations are underway by Derek Glazier to study X and Z production in Hall B with CLAS12:
    • The baseline version of CLAS12 has been assumed augmented with a zero degree photon tagger (mentioned by Volker Burkert in the last discussion) to enable studies of quasi-real photoproduction (at tagging angles below 1 deg).
    • The studies have assumed a luminosity of 1035 cm-2s-1 and 50 days of running.
      • Expected yields: N(X(3872))=2-3k, N(Zc(3900))=25k
  • Work has begun to estimate backgrounds from existing measurements, specifically from data taken at COMPASS on π±N but more work is needed to make these studies realistic.

• Questions from discussion:
  • What about measuring open charm decays given the increased backgrounds that are to be expected?
  • What about measuring polarization observables?
  • What about establishing strange quark partners of states, e.g. Zc → πJ/Ψ, Zcs → KJ/Ψ?
  • What about radiative decays of X(3872)?
    • Can this be estimated? Are such studies useful?
    • How do backgrounds affect this channel?
  • The main comment from the discussion is that realistic backgrounds must be included in the different simulations to enable more realistic modeling and impact statements to be made.
    • Can such studies be advanced for the upcoming December 22 GeV workshop?